The Difference Between Lumify and Systane
Before combining any two eye drops, it is crucial to understand their distinct purposes. Lumify is a redness reliever, while Systane is a lubricating eye drop designed to combat dry eye symptoms. Their active ingredients and mechanisms of action are completely different, which is the primary reason why they can be used together safely with the right technique.
Lumify: For Ocular Redness
Lumify's active ingredient is a low-dose brimonidine tartrate (0.025%). It works by selectively targeting and constricting the small, visible blood vessels in the eye that cause redness. Unlike older redness relievers that constrict all blood vessels and can lead to a 'rebound effect' (where eyes become redder than before as the effect wears off), Lumify's formulation minimizes this risk when used as directed. It is a temporary solution for occasional red eyes caused by mild irritation, fatigue, or environmental factors. The effect is quick, often working within a minute, and lasts up to eight hours.
Systane: For Dry Eye Relief
Systane is a brand of artificial tears formulated to provide moisture and lubrication for dry, irritated eyes. The Systane product line includes various formulations, such as drops, gels, and ointments, each designed for different levels of dry eye severity. They work by supplementing the eye's natural tears, helping to protect and moisten the outer surface of the eye. Systane's purpose is to treat the discomfort, burning, and irritation associated with dry eye syndrome, rather than addressing redness specifically.
How to Use Lumify and Systane Together Safely
The key to using Lumify and Systane together is to space out the applications properly to prevent one drop from washing out the other. Waiting at least five minutes between drops allows each medication enough time to be absorbed by the eye's surface before the next is introduced. Experts generally recommend applying the thinner, medicated drop first, followed by the thicker, lubricating drop.
Application Steps:
- Wash Hands: Always wash your hands thoroughly before handling any eye drops to avoid contamination.
- Remove Contacts: If you wear contact lenses, remove them before applying Lumify. Lumify contains a preservative that can be absorbed by soft contact lenses.
- Apply Lumify: Tilt your head back and gently pull down your lower eyelid. Instill one drop of Lumify in the affected eye(s).
- Wait 5 Minutes: Close your eyes gently and wait at least five minutes to allow the Lumify to work.
- Apply Systane: After waiting, apply the Systane lubricating drops as needed for dryness. If using a gel or ointment version of Systane, apply it last.
- Wait for Contacts: If you removed contact lenses, wait at least ten minutes after the final eye drop application before reinserting them.
Comparing Lumify and Systane
| Feature | Lumify (Brimonidine Tartrate 0.025%) | Systane (Artificial Tears) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Purpose | Relieves eye redness by constricting blood vessels. | Lubricates and moisturizes for dry eye relief. |
| Active Ingredient | Brimonidine Tartrate | Polyethylene Glycol, Propylene Glycol, or others (depending on formulation) |
| Onset of Action | Works in approximately 1 minute | Provides near-immediate moisture and soothing relief |
| Duration of Effect | Lasts up to 8 hours | Varies depending on the formulation and severity of dryness |
| Key Precautions | Do not use more than 4 times daily. | Many formulations are safe for frequent use, but preservatives can be irritating for some. |
| Contact Lenses | Remove before use. Wait 10 mins to reinsert. | Remove if using a formula with preservatives; preservative-free versions are often contact lens safe. |
Important Considerations for Eye Health
Using eye drops correctly is vital for their effectiveness and your eye health. If you use multiple medicated eye drops for conditions like glaucoma, a five-minute separation is also recommended to ensure full absorption. Furthermore, to minimize the risk of contamination, never touch the dropper tip to any surface, including your eye, eyelid, or fingers.
For individuals with sensitive eyes or those who use lubricating drops frequently, preservative-free versions of artificial tears like Systane Complete PF may be a better option. Overuse of drops containing preservatives can sometimes cause irritation. If you have any underlying medical conditions, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or are taking other medications, consult with your eye care provider or a doctor before starting a new regimen.
Conclusion
In short, can you use Lumify and Systane? Yes, you can. They address different ocular issues—Lumify for redness and Systane for dryness—and can be part of a combined approach to eye comfort. The most critical step is adhering to the waiting period of at least five minutes between applications to ensure each drop works as intended. By understanding each product's purpose and following proper application techniques, you can safely manage both redness and dryness for healthier-looking and more comfortable eyes. If symptoms persist or worsen after 72 hours, discontinue use and consult an ophthalmologist for a proper diagnosis and treatment plan.
