A common and potentially harmful misconception is the belief that taking extra regular birth control pills can function as effective emergency contraception (EC). This idea stems from an outdated practice called the Yuzpe method, which is significantly different from using a dedicated EC pill like Plan B. The core difference lies in the hormone content and the medication's specific purpose. While dedicated EC pills contain a high, targeted dose of hormones to delay or prevent ovulation, standard birth control pills contain a lower, consistent dose for daily use. Taking an insufficient number of regular pills will not prevent pregnancy, and attempting to mimic an EC dose with regular pills is less effective and comes with more side effects.
The Core Difference: Regular Pills vs. Emergency Contraception
Regular birth control pills are designed for consistent, daily use to suppress ovulation and thicken cervical mucus, preventing pregnancy over an entire cycle. They contain lower doses of hormones (progestin and often estrogen) to maintain a steady hormonal level. Emergency contraceptive pills, like Plan B, are designed for a one-time, high-dose treatment to prevent pregnancy after a single instance of unprotected sex. The higher dose of hormones in EC is necessary to disrupt the menstrual cycle and delay ovulation effectively, but this is a temporary measure, not a consistent form of contraception.
Hormonal differences in EC pills:
- Plan B (levonorgestrel): This over-the-counter EC pill contains a single, high dose of levonorgestrel, a synthetic progestin. It works by delaying or stopping the release of an egg from the ovary.
- Ella (ulipristal acetate): This is a more effective EC pill that requires a prescription. Ulipristal is a different compound that acts on progesterone receptors to delay or inhibit ovulation.
The Outdated Yuzpe Method: A Less Effective Alternative
The Yuzpe method was developed before dedicated EC pills were widely available and involves taking a specific, calculated number of combined birth control pills in two doses, 12 hours apart. This method is now considered outdated and is not the preferred option for emergency contraception for several important reasons:
- Lower Effectiveness: Studies show the Yuzpe method is significantly less effective than dedicated EC pills. While Plan B is around 75-89% effective within 72 hours, the Yuzpe method's pregnancy prevention rate is much lower, sometimes cited as low as 74%.
- Increased Side Effects: The Yuzpe method involves a higher dosage of estrogen, which leads to a higher rate of side effects, most notably severe nausea and vomiting. This can compromise the treatment's effectiveness if the user vomits shortly after taking a dose.
- Complex Dosage: The exact number of pills required for the Yuzpe method varies widely depending on the specific brand and hormone content of the birth control pill, making it confusing and prone to error.
Dedicated Emergency Contraception: The Better Choice
When considering emergency contraception, the choice is clear: dedicated EC pills or an IUD are the safest and most effective options. Relying on an unproven, DIY method like taking a random number of birth control pills is risky and less reliable. For reliable post-coital pregnancy prevention, one of the following methods is recommended:
- Plan B One-Step (and generics like Take Action, My Way): An over-the-counter option containing levonorgestrel, effective for up to 72 hours after unprotected sex, but works best the sooner it's taken.
- Ella (ulipristal acetate): A prescription option that is more effective than Plan B and can be taken up to 120 hours (five days) after unprotected sex.
- Copper IUD: The most effective form of emergency contraception, which can be inserted by a healthcare provider up to five days after unprotected sex and also provides long-term contraception.
Comparison of Emergency Contraception Methods
| Feature | Plan B (Levonorgestrel) | Ella (Ulipristal Acetate) | Yuzpe Method (Multiple Birth Control Pills) | Copper IUD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Availability | Over-the-counter | Prescription | Using existing prescription pills | Healthcare provider insertion |
| Time Frame | Up to 72 hours (3 days) | Up to 120 hours (5 days) | Up to 72 hours (3 days) | Up to 120 hours (5 days) |
| Effectiveness | 75-89% (most effective if taken early) | ~85-98% (better than Plan B after 72 hours) | Less effective than dedicated EC, around 74% | >99% effective |
| Hormone(s) | Progestin only (levonorgestrel) | Ulipristal acetate | Progestin and Estrogen | None (copper) |
| Primary Side Effects | Nausea, headache, dizziness, fatigue | Similar to Plan B | Severe nausea, vomiting, headache, breast tenderness | Cramping, heavier periods |
| Considerations | Readily available, but less effective over time. | Requires prescription, highly effective. | Outdated, less effective, more side effects. | Most effective, long-term option, requires appointment. |
Safety and Side Effects of Using Multiple Pills
While taking a slightly higher dose of hormones won't cause immediate serious harm in most people, it's not without consequences. Taking an incorrect, large dose of oral contraceptives can increase side effects, such as:
- Significant nausea and vomiting
- Headaches and dizziness
- Breast tenderness
- Breakthrough bleeding or spotting
- Changes in your next menstrual period
It's important to understand that if you vomit within a few hours of taking the pills, their effectiveness can be reduced, and a healthcare provider should be consulted. Repeatedly relying on this method or taking an uncontrolled dose is not a safe or reliable practice.
What to Do After Unprotected Sex
If you have had unprotected sex or experienced contraceptive failure, follow these steps to ensure you are taking the most effective action:
- Assess the timeline: EC is most effective when taken as soon as possible. Plan B should be taken within 72 hours, and Ella within 120 hours.
- Seek dedicated EC: The best and safest option is to purchase a dedicated emergency contraceptive pill like Plan B from a pharmacy. Many generic versions are also available and are just as effective. If you have a prescription for Ella, that is also a highly effective choice.
- Consider a Copper IUD: The most effective method is a copper IUD, which a doctor can insert within five days of unprotected sex.
- Do not rely on the Yuzpe method: Unless no other option is available and with careful calculation, avoid using regular birth control pills for EC due to their reduced effectiveness and increased side effects.
- Follow-up: After taking EC, use a backup method of contraception, like condoms, until your next period. If your period is significantly delayed, take a pregnancy test.
Conclusion: Don't Take the Risk
When it comes to preventing an unintended pregnancy, relying on a misconception like 'does taking two birth control equal a Plan B?' is an unnecessary risk. Dedicated emergency contraception pills like Plan B and Ella are formulated specifically for post-intercourse prevention and are significantly more effective and reliable. While the Yuzpe method using multiple regular birth control pills exists, it is an outdated, less effective alternative with more side effects. For the highest chance of preventing pregnancy, dedicated EC should be your first and only choice. For the most effective option, consider a copper IUD, which also offers long-term protection.
Visit Bedsider for more information on emergency contraception.
