The History of an Iconic Brand
Introduced in 1948 by Armour and Company, Dial was the first antibacterial soap available to consumers in the U.S.. Initially containing hexachlorophene, it was reformulated with triclocarban and triclosan after hexachlorophene was removed from the market. Dial's marketing historically emphasized its germ-killing abilities.
The FDA's 2016 Ruling and a Major Shift
A significant industry change occurred on September 2, 2016, when the FDA banned 19 active ingredients, including triclosan and triclocarban, from over-the-counter consumer antiseptic washes. This decision was based on a lack of evidence that these ingredients offered greater effectiveness than plain soap and water for preventing illness, along with concerns about long-term risks such as bacterial resistance and hormonal effects. The FDA deemed the potential risks of triclosan to outweigh its benefits for the average consumer, prompting manufacturers like Dial to reformulate.
Dial's New Active Ingredient: Benzalkonium Chloride
Following the FDA's ban, Dial replaced triclosan and triclocarban with benzalkonium chloride in its bar and liquid soaps. Benzalkonium chloride is a quaternary ammonium compound used in antibacterial products for decades. It functions by disrupting microbial cell membranes, effectively killing a wide range of bacteria. Dial claims its formulas with benzalkonium chloride eliminate 99.9% or 99.99% of common household bacteria in 30 seconds. This ingredient was not included in the 2016 ban, but the FDA requested more safety and effectiveness data while allowing products containing it to remain available.
How Does Antibacterial Soap Compare to Plain Soap?
Unlike antibacterial soaps that aim to kill bacteria, plain soap works by using molecules that dissolve and lift germs from the skin, which are then washed away with water. {Link: WAXIE info.waxie.com/antibacterial-update}. The FDA and CDC state there's no evidence antibacterial soaps are more effective than plain soap and water for preventing illness. The FDA highlights washing with plain soap and water as crucial. Experts also express concerns about potential antibiotic resistance and disruption of skin's natural bacterial balance with excessive antibacterial use.
Comparison of Soap Types
Feature | Plain Soap | Triclosan-Based Soap (Pre-2017) | Benzalkonium Chloride Soap (Current Dial) |
---|---|---|---|
Mechanism | Mechanically removes germs | Aims to kill bacteria on contact | Aims to kill bacteria on contact |
Active Agent | None | Triclosan | Benzalkonium Chloride |
FDA Status | Recommended for general use | Banned from OTC consumer soaps in 2016 | Permitted, but under review for more data |
Effectiveness vs. Plain Soap | - | No proven extra benefit for illness prevention | No proven extra benefit for illness prevention |
Potential Risks | Minimal, can cause dryness. | Bacterial resistance, hormonal effects | Skin irritation, potential for resistance |
Conclusion: So, Is Dial Soap Antibacterial?
Yes, Dial soap is formulated to be antibacterial with benzalkonium chloride. However, health authorities emphasize no established evidence that antibacterial soap offers superior benefits over plain soap and water for preventing illness during routine hygiene. Proper handwashing for at least 20 seconds is key. While antibacterial, it's not necessarily more effective than regular soap for staying healthy. For handwashing guidelines, visit the CDC's Handwashing page.