From Animal Pancreases to Microbe Factories
Before modern genetic engineering, insulin was extracted from animal pancreases, mainly cattle and pigs, starting in the 1920s. This was the primary method for decades but had drawbacks like dependence on the meatpacking industry and differences from human insulin. Porcine insulin varies by one amino acid, while bovine differs by three. These variations could cause allergic and immune reactions.
By the 1980s, increased demand and concerns about purity and supply led to the adoption of recombinant DNA technology. This allowed microorganisms like bacteria or yeast to produce therapeutic proteins. The first biosynthetic human insulin, Humulin, was FDA-approved in 1982, initiating the move away from animal sources.
How Modern Biosynthetic Human Insulin is Made
Modern insulin production uses genetic engineering for a pure, consistent, and abundant supply chemically identical to human insulin.
The process typically involves:
Creating the Recombinant DNA
- Isolating the Human Insulin Gene: The human insulin gene is identified.
- Creating Plasmids: A circular DNA piece called a plasmid is taken from a microorganism host, such as E. coli or yeast.
- Inserting the Gene: The human insulin gene is inserted into the plasmid using enzymes, creating a recombinant plasmid.
Mass Production and Purification
- Bacterial Transformation: Recombinant plasmids are put into host bacteria, which become genetically modified to produce human insulin.
- Fermentation: Modified bacteria multiply in tanks, producing human insulin.
- Extraction and Purification: Insulin is harvested and purified in multiple steps, removing bacteria and impurities for a highly pure product.
Comparison of Animal vs. Biosynthetic Insulin
This comparison highlights differences between animal-based and modern biosynthetic human insulin.
Feature | Animal-Sourced Insulin (e.g., Porcine) | Biosynthetic Human Insulin |
---|---|---|
Source | Pancreases of pigs or cattle | Genetically engineered microorganisms (bacteria or yeast) |
Chemical Structure | Not chemically identical to human insulin (porcine differs by one amino acid) | Chemically identical to the insulin produced by the human pancreas |
Purity | Less pure, can contain trace impurities | High purity |
Risk of Allergic Reaction | Higher risk | Significantly lower risk |
Supply | Limited, dependent on the meat industry | Virtually unlimited, scalable |
Availability | Mostly discontinued in developed countries (US: porcine in 2006) | Widely available and standard of care |
Cost | Historically cost-intensive due to extraction process | Production more efficient and scalable, costs remain complex |
The Current Status of Animal Insulin
For most patients in developed countries, animal-sourced insulin is no longer the standard. Its voluntary discontinuation in the US, including porcine insulin in 2006, means it's not FDA-approved for domestic sale. However, a small number of patients who respond better may still acquire it under special conditions. Companies like Wockhardt UK continue limited production for specific markets and individual import. Most healthcare providers use modern biosynthetic human insulin and its analogues.
Conclusion
While insulin was once derived from pigs and cattle, this is largely a part of history. The shift to biosynthetic human insulin using genetic engineering has greatly improved diabetes management. It addressed issues of limited supply, inconsistency, and allergic reactions associated with animal-sourced insulin. Today's insulin is purer, more reliable, and safer, offering better treatment options and peace of mind.