What is Salonpas?
Salonpas is a brand of over-the-counter (OTC) topical pain relief products, famously known for its medicated patches. These patches are applied directly to the skin over the affected area to deliver pain-relieving medication transdermally. Depending on the specific product, Salonpas patches can contain different active ingredients, including:
- Menthol: A counterirritant that provides a cooling sensation on the skin, which distracts the brain from the underlying pain.
- Methyl salicylate: A topical analgesic that also acts as a counterirritant and provides anti-inflammatory effects.
- Camphor: Another counterirritant that produces a warm feeling and helps distract from pain.
- Lidocaine: Some Salonpas products contain lidocaine, a topical anesthetic that works by numbing the nerves in the applied area.
How does Salonpas work?
The primary mechanism of Salonpas' most common products is counterirritation. The active ingredients like menthol and methyl salicylate stimulate the nerve endings in the skin, creating a sensation of heat or cold. This sensation essentially overloads the pain receptors, diverting the brain's attention and temporarily alleviating the perception of pain. For products containing lidocaine, the mechanism is to block nerve signals from transmitting pain to the brain.
What is Voltaren?
Voltaren is a brand of topical gel that is also available over-the-counter. Its active ingredient is diclofenac sodium, a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID). Voltaren was previously a prescription-only medication and is now available in full-strength OTC formulations, primarily for arthritis pain.
How does Voltaren work?
Unlike the counterirritation method of Salonpas, Voltaren's mechanism is rooted in its NSAID properties. Diclofenac works by blocking the production of prostaglandins, which are specific chemicals in the body responsible for causing pain and inflammation. When applied topically, the gel penetrates the skin to deliver the medication directly to the source of pain in the underlying tissues and joints. This targeted delivery treats the inflammation causing the pain, rather than simply masking the sensation.
Comparison: Is Salonpas the same as Voltaren?
| Feature | Salonpas | Voltaren | Key Distinction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Active Ingredient | Menthol, Methyl Salicylate, Camphor, Lidocaine (product dependent) | Diclofenac Sodium (NSAID) | Salonpas uses counterirritants/numbing agents; Voltaren uses an anti-inflammatory drug. |
| Mechanism of Action | Counterirritation (heating/cooling) and nerve numbing | Blocks pain-causing chemicals (prostaglandins) at the source of inflammation | Salonpas distracts from pain; Voltaren treats the root cause of inflammation. |
| Formulation | Patches (including lidocaine patches), gels, and sprays | Gel formulation (Emulgel™) | Patch vs. Gel application is a major difference in user experience. |
| Primary Use | Temporary relief of mild to moderate muscle aches, strains, and sprains | Arthritis pain in smaller joints like hands, knees, elbows, ankles, and feet | Salonpas is for general musculoskeletal pain; Voltaren is specifically targeted for arthritis in certain joints. |
| Duration of Relief | Up to 8 or 12 hours depending on the product | Can provide relief for an extended period with regular use | Patches provide a set duration; gel efficacy builds with repeated use. |
| Application Area | Broadly for muscles and joints across the body | Specifically recommended for small to medium joints (hands, wrists, elbows, knees, ankles, feet) | Voltaren should not be used on the back, hip, or shoulders. |
| Potential Side Effects | Localized skin reactions (rash, itching), allergic reactions (especially to methyl salicylate or latex) | Systemic NSAID side effects (though minimal for topical use), potential for drug interactions with other NSAIDs | Voltaren has more potential for systemic side effects and interactions than typical Salonpas products. |
When to Choose Salonpas vs. Voltaren
Choosing between these two topical pain relievers depends on the specific type of pain you are experiencing and its underlying cause. Neither product is universally better; they are designed for different pain management scenarios.
-
Choose Salonpas if:
- You have mild to moderate pain from minor muscle aches, strains, or sprains.
- Your pain is not primarily caused by arthritis-related inflammation.
- You prefer a patch for targeted, long-lasting relief without reapplication.
- You are sensitive to NSAIDs or are taking oral NSAIDs that may have a drug interaction with topical diclofenac.
-
Choose Voltaren if:
- Your pain is specifically related to arthritis in your hands, wrists, elbows, knees, ankles, or feet.
- The pain is caused by inflammation, and you need a targeted anti-inflammatory effect.
- You prefer a gel that can be massaged into the joint.
- You are not taking other NSAIDs or have been advised by a doctor that it is safe.
Final considerations and safety
It is crucial to remember that topical medications are not without risk and can interact with other drugs, especially for Voltaren. Always consult your healthcare provider or pharmacist, particularly if you have pre-existing health conditions like heart, kidney, or liver disease, or are taking other medications. Both products have specific application instructions regarding duration and frequency that must be followed carefully to minimize side effects. For example, Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel is approved for daily use for up to 21 consecutive days before consulting a doctor, while Salonpas patches have shorter consecutive use recommendations. Adhering to these guidelines ensures both safety and effectiveness.
Conclusion
While both Salonpas and Voltaren offer effective topical pain relief, they are fundamentally different medications. Salonpas uses counterirritants like menthol and methyl salicylate to mask pain or lidocaine to numb the nerves, making it suitable for general muscle aches and sprains. In contrast, Voltaren uses the NSAID diclofenac to directly reduce inflammation, making it a targeted treatment for arthritis pain in specific joints. By understanding the distinct mechanisms and appropriate uses for each, you can make an informed decision and choose the product that best addresses your specific type of pain. Always read the product label and consult a healthcare professional with any questions or concerns.
For additional information regarding the safety and proper usage of topical analgesics, the DailyMed database is an excellent resource provided by the U.S. National Library of Medicine.
