Skip to content

Is Yaz the Best Birth Control Pill? An Objective Look at Benefits, Risks, and Alternatives

4 min read

According to the CDC, approximately 25% of women who use contraception in the U.S. choose the birth control pill. While Yaz is a popular brand, the question of whether it is the best birth control pill is a complex one that depends entirely on an individual's health, lifestyle, and needs.

Quick Summary

An evaluation of the benefits and risks of Yaz, examining its efficacy, side effects, and specific approved uses for acne and PMDD. The article provides a comparison with alternative contraceptive options and outlines the key factors for choosing the right pill for your health.

Key Points

  • Specific Indications: Yaz is FDA-approved for treating moderate acne and Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD) in addition to preventing pregnancy.

  • Increased Blood Clot Risk: Yaz contains the progestin drospirenone, which has been linked to a slightly higher risk of serious blood clots compared to some older birth control pills.

  • Contraindicated for Certain Groups: Yaz is not suitable for women over 35 who smoke, or those with a history of blood clots, heart disease, or migraines with aura.

  • Unique Progestin Benefits: Drospirenone's diuretic-like properties can help reduce bloating and water retention, a benefit not found in many other pills.

  • Highly Individualized Choice: The "best" birth control pill depends on a woman's individual health history, lifestyle, and treatment goals, necessitating a consultation with a healthcare provider.

  • Side Effects and Adjustments: Common side effects like nausea and irregular bleeding often improve within the first three months as the body adjusts to the hormones.

In This Article

What is Yaz and How Does it Work?

Yaz is a combination oral contraceptive (COC) containing two active ingredients: ethinyl estradiol, a synthetic estrogen, and drospirenone, a synthetic progestin. What distinguishes Yaz from many other birth control pills is its progestin component, drospirenone, a fourth-generation progestin with unique properties. A standard pack of Yaz contains 24 active hormone pills and four inactive placebo pills, a different regimen than the traditional 21/7-day cycle.

These two hormones work together to prevent pregnancy through several key mechanisms:

  • Inhibiting Ovulation: The hormones prevent the ovaries from releasing an egg, so there is nothing for sperm to fertilize.
  • Thickening Cervical Mucus: They alter the cervical mucus, making it thicker and stickier. This creates a barrier that makes it more difficult for sperm to travel to the uterus.
  • Thinning the Uterine Lining: The hormones thin the lining of the uterus. This makes it more difficult for a fertilized egg to implant and develop.

The Benefits of Taking Yaz

Beyond its primary function as a contraceptive, Yaz offers several benefits that appeal to many women, leading to its widespread use and popularity. The FDA has specifically approved Yaz for several indications beyond pregnancy prevention:

  • Treating Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD): Yaz is one of the few oral contraceptives approved to treat the emotional and physical symptoms of PMDD, a severe form of PMS. It helps balance hormone levels to manage symptoms like mood swings, irritability, and bloating.
  • Treating Moderate Acne: For women who are at least 14 years old, Yaz is an FDA-approved treatment for moderate acne. Its anti-androgenic properties help to reduce the body's testosterone levels, leading to less oil production and fewer acne lesions.

Additional potential benefits reported by some users include:

  • Lighter and more regular periods.
  • Less bloating and water retention due to drospirenone's diuretic-like properties.
  • Reduced menstrual pain.

Risks and Potential Side Effects of Yaz

While Yaz can be highly effective and beneficial, it is not without risks. The most serious risk is the increased potential for blood clots, which can lead to serious cardiovascular events like deep vein thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary embolism (PE), stroke, or heart attack.

  • Increased Blood Clot Risk: Studies suggest that birth control pills containing drospirenone carry a higher risk of blood clots compared to pills with older progestins. For women over 35 who smoke, this risk is significantly higher, leading to a black box warning on Yaz packaging.
  • Hyperkalemia (High Potassium Levels): The drospirenone in Yaz can interfere with the kidneys' ability to regulate potassium, posing a risk of elevated potassium levels. Women with kidney, liver, or adrenal disease should not take Yaz.
  • Other Contraindications: Yaz is not recommended for women with a history of blood clots, heart disease, certain cancers (especially breast cancer), uncontrolled high blood pressure, or migraines with aura.

Common, but less severe, side effects may also occur, particularly during the first few months of use, as the body adjusts:

  • Headaches or migraines
  • Irregular bleeding or spotting between periods
  • Nausea or vomiting
  • Breast pain or tenderness
  • Mood changes or depression

Yaz vs. Other Birth Control Pills

Evaluating if Yaz is the best option requires understanding how it compares to other available oral contraceptives. The choice depends on weighing the benefits, hormone levels, and specific risks of different formulations.

Comparison Table: Yaz vs. Common Alternatives

Feature Yaz (Drospirenone/Ethinyl Estradiol) Yasmin (Drospirenone/Ethinyl Estradiol) Generic Option (e.g., Syeda) Progestin-Only Pill (Minipill, e.g., Slynd)
Hormones Drospirenone (3mg) & Ethinyl Estradiol (20mcg) Drospirenone (3mg) & Ethinyl Estradiol (30mcg) Contains same active hormones as Yaz Drospirenone (4mg) only
Indications Pregnancy prevention, PMDD, moderate acne Pregnancy prevention only Pregnancy prevention, PMDD, moderate acne Pregnancy prevention
Dosing Cycle 24 active pills, 4 placebo pills 21 active pills, 7 placebo pills 24 active pills, 4 placebo pills 24 active pills, 4 placebo pills (differing drospirenone dose)
Estrogen Content Low dose Higher dose Low dose None
Blood Clot Risk Slightly elevated compared to older COCs Slightly elevated compared to older COCs Same as Yaz Safe for some women who cannot take estrogen

How to Decide: Is Yaz for You?

Because no single birth control is perfect for everyone, a thorough discussion with a healthcare provider is essential. When considering Yaz, here are some key questions to discuss:

  • Do you have PMDD or hormonal acne? Yaz's FDA-approved benefits for these specific conditions may make it a preferable choice if you suffer from them.
  • Do you have risk factors for blood clots? If you smoke (especially over 35), have a history of blood clots, or certain cardiovascular conditions, Yaz may be contraindicated. A progestin-only pill or non-hormonal method may be safer.
  • Are you prone to bloating or water retention? Drospirenone's diuretic effect might be beneficial for those who experience these symptoms on other pills.
  • What is your experience with mood changes? Some users report mood swings or depression on Yaz. If you are sensitive to hormonal fluctuations, this is an important factor to consider.
  • What dosing schedule do you prefer? Yaz's 24/4 schedule can result in shorter, lighter periods compared to a traditional 21/7 regimen.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Choice

Is Yaz the best birth control pill? For women seeking treatment for PMDD or moderate acne alongside contraception, its unique properties and FDA approvals make it a strong candidate. However, the increased risk of blood clots compared to other oral contraceptives, as noted by the FDA, means it is not the right choice for everyone, particularly those with existing risk factors. Ultimately, there is no single "best" birth control pill. The optimal contraceptive method is a personal decision that should be made in consultation with a qualified healthcare provider, who can assess your individual health history, lifestyle, and priorities to find the safest and most effective option for you.

For further information on contraception, consult reputable health organizations like the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

Frequently Asked Questions

The main difference is the type of progestin hormone it contains. Yaz uses drospirenone, a fourth-generation progestin with diuretic-like properties, which can help reduce bloating. It also has specific FDA approvals for treating PMDD and moderate acne, unlike many other pills.

Some studies have suggested that birth control pills containing drospirenone, including Yaz, may carry a slightly higher risk of blood clots compared to pills containing other progestins. The risk is still relatively low, but it's an important factor for certain individuals, especially smokers over 35 or those with a history of blood clots.

Yes, Yaz is FDA-approved to treat moderate acne in women 14 years and older. Its anti-androgenic properties help reduce the production of testosterone, which can lead to less oil production and fewer breakouts.

Yaz is not recommended for women over 35 who smoke, or those with a history of blood clots, heart disease, liver or adrenal issues, or migraines with aura. It is essential to discuss your full medical history with your doctor before starting Yaz.

Common side effects include headaches, irregular bleeding, breast tenderness, and nausea. These often improve over the first few months. Some users also report mood swings.

Both contain drospirenone and ethinyl estradiol but differ in dosage and schedule. Yaz contains a lower dose of estrogen (20mcg) and has a 24/4 dosing schedule, while Yasmin has a higher estrogen dose (30mcg) and a 21/7 schedule. Additionally, Yaz is approved for PMDD and acne, but Yasmin is not.

Yes, several generic versions of Yaz are available, which typically contain the same active ingredients at a lower cost. Branded generics include Nikki, Loryna, and Vestura.

Yes, the drospirenone in Yaz has anti-mineralocorticoid activity, meaning it can counteract fluid retention. This can help some women experience less bloating and weight gain related to fluid retention compared to other pills.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.