A Deep-Rooted Tradition: Hai Ma in Chinese Medicine
Dried seahorse, known as Hai Ma in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), has been a valued ingredient for centuries. TCM theory associates seahorses with warm properties and the Kidney and Liver meridians, leading to their use for various ailments. Practitioners believe seahorses can 'tonify kidney and activate Yang,' which is central to their application.
The most common traditional use is as an aphrodisiac and treatment for sexual dysfunction. They are also used for respiratory issues like asthma, throat infections, skin conditions, insomnia, and abdominal pain. Traditionally, the seahorse is sun-dried and then powdered or added to soups and rice wine. A typical dose is 1-3 grams of powder, often mixed with other herbs.
The Scientific Evidence vs. Traditional Claims
Modern science largely does not support the traditional claims surrounding dried seahorse in humans. While some laboratory studies on seahorse extracts or peptides have shown potential anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, or anti-fatigue effects in animal or cell models, these findings are preliminary. For example, one study found a seahorse peptide effective on arthritic cartilage cells in a lab, and another suggested an extract might improve fertility in rats.
However, these lab results do not prove that consuming whole dried seahorse provides any benefit to people. The Seahorse Trust and other sources state there is no scientific basis for the medicinal claims.
Comparison: Traditional Belief vs. Scientific Fact
Claimed Benefit | Traditional Belief (TCM) | Scientific Evidence |
---|---|---|
Aphrodisiac / Impotence | Boosts kidney 'yang' energy, improves blood flow, and enhances sexual vitality. Pregnant males are considered especially potent. | No credible clinical trials or scientific evidence support this claim in humans. Some rat studies showed a tendency for increased testosterone but were not definitive. |
Asthma and Respiratory Issues | Reduces phlegm, relieves coughs, and calms wheezing. | No clinical evidence exists. Lab studies on peptides show anti-inflammatory potential, but this hasn't been tested in humans for asthma. |
Arthritis and Pain Relief | Invigorates blood circulation to alleviate pain. | One lab study noted a specific peptide was effective on arthritic cartilage cells, but this does not prove human efficacy. |
Anti-Aging | Possesses a free-radical scavenging effect. | Antioxidant compounds are found in seahorses, but anti-aging effects are unproven in humans. |
The Overwhelming Conservation Crisis
Demand for dried seahorses severely impacts wild populations, pushing many species towards extinction. An estimated 150 million seahorses are used annually in the trade. Most are caught as bycatch in shrimp trawling, destroying other marine life too.
All 44 seahorse species were listed under CITES Appendix II in 2002, requiring sustainable trade. Despite this, illegal trade is massive, with millions smuggled yearly. Many species sold are classified as 'Vulnerable' or 'Endangered' by the IUCN. The trade targets pregnant males, removing many potential offspring.
Are There Alternatives?
Due to the lack of scientific support and severe environmental harm, using dried seahorse is problematic. Proven medical treatments exist for the ailments it claims to treat, such as medications for erectile dysfunction and asthma.
Sustainable alternatives are also emerging within TCM. Some practitioners are replacing endangered species with plant-based remedies or other herbal formulations like fenugreek seeds, Epimedium, or Ba-Wei Di-Huang Pills, which offer similar theoretical benefits without threatening marine life.
Conclusion: An Unsustainable and Unproven Practice
The use of dried seahorse represents a conflict between tradition, science, and environmental responsibility. Despite its historical role in TCM, scientific evidence for its health benefits is lacking. The enormous trade it fuels, often illegal, has driven many seahorse species towards extinction and harmed marine ecosystems. For consumers, the environmental risks far outweigh any unproven benefits, making its consumption ethically and environmentally unsustainable. Modern treatments and sustainable herbal options provide a responsible path forward.
For more information on seahorse conservation, you can visit Project Seahorse.