ARBs vs. ACE Inhibitors: A Pharmacological Distinction
To understand why angiotensin receptor blockers (ARBs) are much less likely to cause a persistent cough or angioedema than angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEIs), it is essential to look at their different mechanisms of action within the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS).
The ACE Inhibitor Mechanism
ACEIs, which typically end in "-pril," work by blocking the angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE). This enzyme is responsible for converting angiotensin I into angiotensin II and also breaking down bradykinin, a vasodilator. By inhibiting ACE, these medications increase bradykinin levels, which is the primary cause of associated side effects like cough and, rarely, angioedema. The accumulation of bradykinin in the lungs can cause cough, while elevated levels can also increase vascular permeability, leading to angioedema.
The ARB Mechanism
ARBs, often ending in "-sartan," block the angiotensin II type 1 (AT1) receptors, preventing angiotensin II from exerting its effects. Unlike ACEIs, ARBs do not inhibit the breakdown of bradykinin, resulting in a significantly lower risk of cough. Clinical studies indicate the frequency of cough with ARBs is similar to placebo.
ARBs and Angioedema: A Small but Real Risk
While angioedema is considerably less common with ARBs than with ACEIs, a small risk still exists. Patients with a history of ACEI-induced angioedema have a slightly increased risk of a similar reaction when switching to an ARB. Some theories suggest this might involve a feedback increase in angiotensin II, potentially leading to minor ACE inhibition or activation of AT2 receptors, contributing to bradykinin generation in susceptible individuals.
Comparing ACE Inhibitors and ARBs
Feature | ACE Inhibitors (e.g., Lisinopril, Ramipril) | Angiotensin Receptor Blockers (ARBs) (e.g., Losartan, Valsartan) |
---|---|---|
Mechanism of Action | Inhibits the ACE enzyme, preventing conversion of angiotensin I to angiotensin II and blocking bradykinin breakdown. | Blocks the AT1 receptor, preventing angiotensin II from binding. |
Cough Incidence | High (5-35%). A common reason for discontinuation. | Low (comparable to placebo). Does not affect bradykinin breakdown. |
Angioedema Risk | Low but higher incidence (~0.1-2%) than with ARBs. | Very low, but non-zero. Higher risk in patients with prior ACEI-induced angioedema. |
Associated Substance | High levels of bradykinin. | Low levels of bradykinin, though some increase is possible via alternative pathways in susceptible individuals. |
Switching Therapy | If a cough or angioedema occurs, switching to an ARB is a common clinical practice. | Generally well-tolerated by patients with ACEI-induced side effects, though caution is needed for prior angioedema. |
Management and Clinical Considerations
For patients experiencing an ACEI-induced cough, switching to an ARB is a standard and effective approach, with most patients not developing a cough on the new medication. While switching to an ARB is also considered after ACEI-induced angioedema, it requires careful consideration and monitoring due to the small cross-reactivity risk. Patients should be educated on angioedema symptoms and seek immediate medical attention if they occur while on an ARB. The risk of angioedema in patients without a history of ACEI reaction is very low, but awareness remains crucial.
Conclusion
ARBs present a significantly lower risk of cough and angioedema compared to ACE inhibitors due to their distinct mechanism of action which does not lead to bradykinin accumulation. While the risk of angioedema with ARBs is rare, particularly for those with a prior ACEI reaction, it is not absent. For patients intolerant to ACE inhibitors, ARBs offer a safe and effective treatment alternative for cardiovascular conditions when appropriate precautions are taken and patients are informed about potential symptoms.
For more information on managing ACE inhibitor side effects and ARB use, consult the Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine.