Plan B Effectiveness: A Closer Look at the Data
The phrase "fail rate" implies a fixed percentage, but for emergency contraceptives like Plan B (levonorgestrel), effectiveness is a sliding scale. Studies indicate a wide range of effectiveness depending on the timing of consumption. According to Planned Parenthood, if taken within 72 hours of unprotected sex, Plan B and its generic counterparts are 75% to 89% effective. This means the potential failure rate for users can range from 11% to 25%. However, other data points to even higher success rates within a shorter window. The sooner Plan B is taken, the more effective it is.
- Within 24 hours: Some studies suggest Plan B can be up to 95% effective at preventing pregnancy.
- Within 72 hours: The manufacturer states that Plan B reduces the risk of pregnancy by 81% to 90%.
- Within 120 hours: While some effect may still be present, effectiveness drops significantly after 72 hours, and other options like the prescription pill Ella or a copper IUD are more reliable.
The Primary Reason Plan B Fails: Ovulation
Plan B is not an abortion pill and will not end an existing pregnancy. Its main mechanism of action is to prevent or delay ovulation—the release of an egg from the ovary. If you have already ovulated when you take Plan B, the medication cannot prevent fertilization, and it will be ineffective. This is arguably the most common reason for Plan B failure.
Factors that Influence Plan B's Fail Rate
Beyond timing and ovulation, several other factors can significantly impact the efficacy of Plan B.
-
Body Weight and BMI: Multiple studies have shown that Plan B may be less effective for individuals with higher body weight. Concerns typically arise for those weighing more than 165 pounds or with a body mass index (BMI) of 30 or higher. While the FDA has reviewed this data and found it inconclusive for a label change, some research suggests a decreased blood concentration of the active ingredient, levonorgestrel, in heavier individuals. For these individuals, prescription options like Ella (effective up to 195 pounds) or a copper IUD are often recommended as more reliable alternatives.
-
Drug Interactions: Certain medications can interfere with the way your body metabolizes Plan B, reducing its effectiveness. These include some anti-seizure medications, specific antibiotics, and the herbal supplement St. John's Wort. Always consult with a pharmacist or healthcare provider about potential interactions before taking Plan B.
-
Vomiting: Vomiting within two to three hours of taking Plan B can prevent the full dose from being absorbed by your body. If this occurs, it's recommended to contact a healthcare professional to determine if a repeat dose is necessary.
-
Storage and Expiration: Like any medication, Plan B can lose its potency if it is expired or stored improperly (e.g., in extreme heat). Keeping an unexpired package stored correctly is recommended for emergencies.
Comparison of Emergency Contraception Options
For those weighing their options, here is a comparison of the most common emergency contraception methods available:
| Feature | Plan B (Levonorgestrel) | Ella (Ulipristal Acetate) | Copper IUD (Paragard) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Availability | Over-the-counter | Prescription only | Inserted by a clinician |
| Timeframe | Up to 72 hours (3 days) | Up to 120 hours (5 days) | Up to 120 hours (5 days) |
| Weight Impact | May be less effective for individuals over 165 lbs or with BMI > 30 | More effective than Plan B for individuals over 165 lbs (up to 195 lbs) | Not affected by body weight; most effective option |
| Effectiveness | 81-90% reduced risk within 72 hours | Higher effectiveness, particularly closer to ovulation and throughout the 120-hour window | Over 99% effective |
| Duration | Single-use emergency pill | Single-use emergency pill | Offers continuous long-term contraception for 10-12 years |
What to Do If Plan B Fails
If you have taken Plan B and your menstrual period is more than a week late, it is recommended to take a pregnancy test. This is the only way to know for certain if the medication was unsuccessful. If the test is positive, consulting with a healthcare provider is the next step to discuss your options. It is important to remember that Plan B does not pose any known harm to an existing pregnancy or a developing fetus.
Conclusion
Plan B is a highly effective and safe emergency contraceptive when used correctly and in a timely manner. However, its effectiveness decreases significantly the longer a person waits to take it and is dependent on their ovulation cycle. Crucially, the pill is not effective if taken after ovulation has already occurred. While the overall effectiveness is high, variables such as body weight and certain medications can lower its success rate. For those seeking the most effective option, particularly individuals with higher body weight, or for use in the later end of the five-day window, a prescription-based option like Ella or the highly effective copper IUD may be a better choice. Plan B should always be considered a backup method, not a substitute for regular, reliable birth control. For a comprehensive overview of options, consult with a healthcare provider or a trusted resource like Planned Parenthood.(https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/morning-after-pill-emergency-contraception/which-kind-emergency-contraception-should-i-use)
