The Varying Effectiveness of Levonorgestrel
Levonorgestrel is a synthetic progestin used in a range of contraceptive products, from emergency contraceptive pills (ECPs) to long-acting intrauterine devices (IUDs) and implants. The failure rate is not a single number but depends heavily on the specific product, its correct use, and other individual factors. Evaluating the failure rate for each form is important for understanding its reliability.
The Failure Rate of Levonorgestrel Emergency Contraceptive Pills (ECPs)
Emergency contraception pills containing levonorgestrel, such as Plan B One-Step and its generics, are a backup method to be used after unprotected intercourse. Their effectiveness is time-sensitive, and the failure rate increases significantly the longer you wait to take them.
Studies show that levonorgestrel ECPs can be up to 94% effective at preventing pregnancy when taken within the first 24 hours after unprotected sex. However, their efficacy decreases with time, dropping to about 58% effective within 72 hours. The overall pregnancy (failure) rate after using a levonorgestrel ECP within 72 hours is generally reported to be between 0.6% and 3.0%.
Factors influencing ECP failure:
- Timeliness: The single most important factor is taking the pill as soon as possible. Delaying treatment increases the likelihood of pregnancy.
- Body Weight: Research suggests that levonorgestrel ECPs may be less effective in women with a higher body mass index (BMI), particularly those weighing over 165 pounds or with a BMI over 26 kg/m². Alternatives like ulipristal acetate (Ella) or a copper IUD may be more effective for these individuals.
- Vomiting: If a user vomits within two to three hours of taking the pill, the medication may not be fully absorbed, and a repeat dose may be required.
- Medication Interactions: Certain medications, including some anticonvulsants, rifampin, and the herbal supplement St. John's wort, can interfere with levonorgestrel's effectiveness.
Failure Rates of Levonorgestrel Intrauterine Devices (IUDs)
For long-term, highly effective contraception, levonorgestrel-releasing IUDs (like Mirena, Kyleena, and Liletta) provide a stark contrast to emergency pills. These devices release a continuous, low dose of levonorgestrel directly into the uterus.
The failure rates for these devices are extremely low, with a first-year failure rate of approximately 0.1-0.2%. This level of effectiveness is comparable to or even better than surgical sterilization. The long-term efficacy is also well-documented, with some devices offering highly effective contraception for up to eight years.
Factors influencing IUD failure:
- Expulsion: A small percentage of IUDs are spontaneously expelled from the uterus, most commonly within the first year of use. Users are usually instructed to check for the strings to confirm the device is in place.
- Incorrect Placement: Though rare, incorrect insertion of the device can reduce its effectiveness. Healthcare providers are trained to ensure proper placement.
Comparing Levonorgestrel Failure Rates to Other Contraceptives
To provide context for levonorgestrel's effectiveness, it is useful to compare its failure rates with those of other common contraceptive methods. The table below outlines the first-year failure rates for various options under both 'perfect use' (correct and consistent use) and 'typical use' (realistic use, which may include inconsistencies).
| Method | Levonorgestrel Formulation | Perfect Use Failure Rate | Typical Use Failure Rate | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levonorgestrel IUD | Long-term (Mirena) | 0.1–0.2% | 0.1–0.2% | |
| Emergency Contraceptive Pill (ECP) | Single-dose (Plan B) | N/A (time-dependent) | ~0.6–3.0% (within 72 hrs) | |
| Copper IUD | Non-hormonal (Paragard) | <0.1% | 0.1–0.8% | |
| Implant | Etonogestrel (not LNG) | 0.1% | 0.1% | |
| Combination Oral Contraceptives | Daily pill | 0.3% | 8% | |
| Male Condom | Barrier | 2% | 13% |
Conclusion
The failure rate of levonorgestrel is not a fixed statistic but a variable that is highly dependent on its specific application and proper use. For long-term contraception, hormonal IUDs provide an exceptionally high level of efficacy with a minimal failure rate. In contrast, levonorgestrel emergency pills, while effective, are less reliable and their efficacy diminishes over time and can be impacted by body weight and medication interactions.
Ultimately, no contraceptive method is 100% effective, and effectiveness relies heavily on user adherence and individual factors. Those considering any form of levonorgestrel contraception should consult a healthcare provider to determine the best and most appropriate option for their needs, especially if specific risk factors like body weight or drug interactions are a concern. For emergency contraception, the most effective option is the copper IUD, which is also a long-term method. Regular contraception should be preferred over repeated use of emergency pills.
Planned Parenthood: How effective is the morning-after pill?
