Understanding Trigger Finger
Trigger finger, also known as stenosing tenosynovitis, is a painful condition where a finger or thumb gets stuck in a bent position. It is caused by inflammation and swelling within the tendon sheath, the tunnel-like structure that encases the flexor tendons of the finger. This swelling, sometimes accompanied by a nodule on the tendon, prevents the tendon from gliding smoothly through the sheath, resulting in a locking, catching, or popping sensation when moving the digit. People with certain medical conditions, including diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis, are at a higher risk of developing this condition.
How a Cortisone Shot Works for Trigger Finger
When you get a cortisone shot for trigger finger, a powerful anti-inflammatory medication is injected directly into the affected tendon sheath. The goal is to reduce the inflammation and swelling that is constricting the tendon. By shrinking the inflamed area, the cortisone allows the tendon to move freely again, relieving the catching and locking. The procedure is typically performed in a doctor's office and may involve a local anesthetic to minimize discomfort. Relief can be relatively quick, with many patients reporting improvement within a few days to a week, though it can take longer for full symptom resolution.
Success Rates and Factors Affecting Efficacy
The effectiveness of a cortisone injection can vary from person to person. Studies have shown a wide range of success rates, often between 50% and 90% for the first injection. The thumb is often cited as having a better response to injections than other fingers. Several factors can influence the outcome:
- Condition Severity: Less severe cases tend to respond better than more advanced, chronic cases.
- Underlying Conditions: People with diabetes often experience lower success rates compared to non-diabetics.
- Multiple Injections: If a trigger finger returns after the first injection, a second one may be considered. However, the long-term success rate for repeat injections can be lower. Many physicians will recommend surgery if a patient requires more than two injections.
The Efficacy of Cortisone Shots
- High Initial Success: A significant percentage of patients experience symptom relief after a single injection.
- Variable Duration: Relief can last for months or even years, but the recurrence of symptoms is also possible.
- Thumb Superiority: Clinical studies indicate that injections for trigger thumb have a notably higher success rate than for other fingers.
- Reduced Efficacy with Comorbidities: Patients with diabetes or multiple triggering fingers may see a diminished response to cortisone shots.
- Repeat Injections: While often still beneficial, subsequent injections tend to be less effective and carry a higher risk of complications.
Potential Risks and Side Effects
While generally safe, cortisone shots carry some risks. Common side effects are usually temporary and include pain or a “steroid flare” at the injection site for a day or two. Other potential side effects include:
- Skin Changes: Thinning of the skin or lightening of its color at the injection site can occur, especially in individuals with darker skin tones.
- Tendon Weakening: In rare cases, repeated injections into the same tendon can weaken it, increasing the risk of tendon rupture.
- Increased Blood Sugar: Diabetic patients should monitor their blood sugar closely for several days following the injection, as it can temporarily increase.
- Infection: While rare, there is a small risk of infection at the injection site.
- Fat Atrophy: A loss of fatty tissue under the skin, leading to a visible indentation, can happen.
Alternative Treatments for Trigger Finger
For those who do not find relief with a cortisone shot, or who prefer a different approach, other treatment options are available:
- Activity Modification and Rest: Avoiding activities that involve repetitive or firm gripping can help alleviate symptoms in milder cases.
- Splinting: A splint worn at night can keep the finger straight and rest the tendon.
- Physical Therapy: Gentle stretching exercises and other techniques can improve the range of motion and reduce stiffness.
- Oral Medications: Over-the-counter anti-inflammatory drugs like ibuprofen may help manage pain and swelling.
- Surgery: When conservative treatments fail, surgical release of the A1 pulley is often recommended. This procedure, which can be performed as an open or percutaneous procedure, has a high success rate and is considered the definitive treatment.
Cortisone Shot vs. Other Trigger Finger Treatments
Feature | Cortisone Shot | Splinting | Surgery (Open/Percutaneous) |
---|---|---|---|
Effectiveness | High initially (50-90%), but can recur. Less effective for diabetics or repeat cases. | Modest, most effective for mild cases, often used at night. | Highest success rate, considered a permanent solution. |
Invasiveness | Minimally invasive. Quick in-office procedure. | Non-invasive. Simply worn on the finger. | Invasive procedure, requires an incision or a needle to be inserted. |
Recovery Time | Minimal. Can experience a “flare” for 1-2 days. Full effect can take weeks. | Immediate. Requires consistent use, often 6-9 weeks. | Varies, but can involve several weeks of recovery and hand therapy. |
Side Effects | Skin thinning, discoloration, fat atrophy, risk of tendon weakening (rare), increased blood sugar. | Skin irritation from wearing the splint. | Post-operative pain, scarring, swelling, potential nerve damage, infection (rare). |
Conclusion
A cortisone shot is a highly effective, non-surgical, and minimally invasive first-line treatment for trigger finger, particularly for mild to moderate cases and for the trigger thumb. By directly addressing the inflammation in the tendon sheath, it can resolve the catching and locking symptoms for a significant period. However, it is not a guaranteed permanent cure for all patients. Factors like underlying health conditions (e.g., diabetes), multiple-digit involvement, and repeated injections can lower its effectiveness. For individuals who experience a recurrence after one or two shots or have persistent symptoms, surgical intervention remains the most reliable long-term solution. It is crucial to discuss the potential benefits and risks with a healthcare provider to determine the most suitable course of action for your specific situation. For more detailed information on hand and upper extremity conditions, you can consult The Hand Society, a leading authority on the subject(https://www.assh.org/).